Comparison

BrainDrop vs Shortform

How the two compare on format, depth, habit and price, and where Shortform is stronger.

6 min readUpdated

BrainDrop vs Shortform is a question of how much you want to read. Shortform writes long, chapter-by-chapter guides with commentary that compares books. BrainDrop gives you the key ideas as fun illustrated stories first, with streaks, chests and gems, and lets you go deeper on just the ideas you care about with Ask BrainDrop.

Choose Shortform if

you want the most thorough written guide to a book and you're happy to read for longer.

Choose BrainDrop if

you want the key ideas to be fun and quick by default, and to go deeper only on the ideas you care about.

We make BrainDrop, so we’ve kept this factual. Facts about Shortform come from its App Store listing, checked on . Prices vary by country, so we link to the listing rather than quote them.

BrainDrop vs Shortform at a glance

BrainDropShortform
FormatIllustrated idea cards told as short stories, plus a scrollable Shorts feedOne-page summaries plus long chapter-by-chapter guides with commentary
LibraryA growing library of non-fiction books, about nine ideas eachGuides to popular non-fiction (see their site for the current count)
Time per sittingEach idea is a short read, and you can stop after any oneA one-page summary, or a long guide you read over several sittings
Going deeperAsk BrainDrop on any idea: go deeper, a real example, a simpler version, or how to use itChapter-by-chapter guides that compare each book's ideas with other books
MotivationStreaks with freezes, daily quests that open chests, gems for reading milestones, a Home Screen widgetNot a focus
Helping it stickA quick quiz after each book, a Try this action on every idea, Saved IdeasNotes and highlights
AudioCards can be read aloudAudio narration
PriceFree to download with a free trial, then BrainDrop ProPaid subscription, monthly or annual
DevicesiPhoneiPhone and web

BrainDrop and Shortform, side by side

Reading

Illustrated stories, not walls of text

Each book is about nine idea cards. Every card tells one idea as a short illustrated story and ends with one small thing to try today. Prefer to browse? The Shorts feed lets you scroll through ideas and quotes and open any book that grabs you.

On Shortform: One-page summaries plus long chapter-by-chapter guides with commentary. See Shortform on the App Store

An illustrated idea card in BrainDrop: Your Focus Was Stolen, from Stolen Focus
An idea card
The Shorts feed in BrainDrop: a scrollable feed of illustrated ideas from books
The Shorts feed

Motivation

Small rewards for coming back

Three small quests a day each open a chest, and doing all three opens the daily chest. Streaks keep count, with freezes for the day you forget. Finish books to collect gems, from the first book onwards.

On Shortform: Not a focus. See Shortform on the App Store

The daily chest bursting open with confetti and +30 XP in BrainDrop
Daily quests open chests
Finishing Atomic Habits in BrainDrop: 140 XP, 9 of 9 ideas, a 39-day streak and a quest chest
Finish a book, keep your streak
Earning the Opal gem for 100 books finished in BrainDrop
Gems for reading milestones

Going deeper

Depth when you want it

Tap Ask BrainDrop on any idea to go deeper, get a real example, have it explained more simply, or work out how to use it in your own life.

On Shortform: Chapter-by-chapter guides that compare each book's ideas with other books. See Shortform on the App Store

A book page in BrainDrop: Atomic Habits, 9 key ideas
Every idea in a book
Ask BrainDrop going deeper on an idea in the BrainDrop app
Ask BrainDrop goes deeper on any idea

Screens from the BrainDrop iPhone app. Follow the links to see the other app on the App Store.

What Shortform offers

  • One-page summaries and chapter-by-chapter guides.
  • Guides add analysis that compares a book's ideas with other books.
  • Audio narration of guides.
  • Monthly and annual subscriptions.

Where Shortform is stronger

  • Much more depth per book: chapter-by-chapter guides with commentary.
  • Cross-book analysis, useful for study and serious note-taking.
  • Reads well on a computer through its website.

Why people look beyond Shortform

Shortform’s guides are long and detailed by design. If you want the key ideas first, and depth only on the ideas you choose, a lighter format may fit better. For other options, see the Shortform alternatives.

Questions

Is Shortform more detailed than BrainDrop?

Yes. Shortform's guides go chapter by chapter and add analysis that compares a book with others. BrainDrop gives you the key ideas first and depth on request through Ask BrainDrop.

Is BrainDrop cheaper than Shortform?

We don't compare exact prices here because they vary by country and change often. Shortform is a paid monthly or annual subscription; BrainDrop is free to download with a free trial, then BrainDrop Pro. Check each App Store listing for prices in your country.

Which is better for studying a book?

Shortform, if you want written commentary to study from. BrainDrop is better for getting the ideas to stick day to day, with quizzes and a Try this action on every idea.

Does BrainDrop work on a computer?

BrainDrop is an iPhone app. Shortform also works in a web browser.

Try BrainDrop on iPhone

Illustrated ideas from great non-fiction, with a streak to keep you going and Ask BrainDrop when you want more. Free to download with a free trial.

Download on the App Store

Keep reading